I was born decades too late. Bigger hole = more effect and 200g gives driving power to penetrate. Ruger SP101, 3-inch barrel. What does the group think or better have had experience with Speer 135 grain Gold Dot in a SP101 357 Magnum with a 2.25"barrel. I would go with whichever one you shoot better. Check out wide collections of casual sneakers for men online on monkstory. loads using the same two firearms and the same testing protocols. But overall, for an optimal AR-15 type rifle with suppressor, 5.56 should not be your first option unless you want it for fun or will also be shooting standard velocity ammo and so on. Impact velocity: 1,193 fps (569 lb-ft) The 357 is a handgun round that sees a enjoys some improved preformance as a carbine in a 16-18" barrel. 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel. These little handguns commonly have a cylinder that holds only five cartridges and a barrel that's about two inches long. Of these three criteria, the penetration is the most important. Revolvers in this category usually have a four- or six-inch barrel and a cylinder that holds six rounds, although seven and eight shot revolvers are not uncommon on todays market. Information is primarily from RifleShooter.com. The Remington website lists their 170-grain .30-30 at 2200 fps and 1827 lb-ft, and the shorty Trapper averaged a real-life 1986 fps and 1489 lb-ft: thats less than a 10 percent velocity penalty and an 18 percent energy penalty. The same caliber gun with the same barrel length could even show different results. LMFAO! Click here for a Muzzle Energy graph for the tests in this caliber. Even better, there are revolvers with barrels ~7 . HANDGUN BALLISTICS. This project, and all of its results, is only our fault. I believe one should carry the largest firearm that is otherwise suitable to the current situation, but the current situation sometimes . 158-grain lead SWC handloads, filled with 5.7 grains of Unique. In modern military terms it would be considered an intermediate-caliber round, packing about the same punch as the 7.6239. That helps with muzzle flash, round velocity, and precision. Retained weight: 181.7 gr The .357 was designed in response to crime problems within the U.S during the 1920's through 30's. ATTENTION: Effective Sept 1, 2020, the BBTI Project is in "Archive Status." No further tests will be conducted, but we will maintain this site and data for the use of the firearms community. JHP. Lever-Action Ballistics Comparison: .30-30 vs .357 Magnum, Levi Strauss Blames Lawful Gun Owners for Gun Violence in Communities of Color, SIG SAUER Announces the New KILO8K-ABS Rangefinder and KILO10K-ABA HD Rangefinding Binoculars, Oh, The Humanity: Latest Polling Shows a Majority of Americans Now Oppose an Assault Weapons Ban, Smith & Wesson Announces the New M&P FPC Pistol Caliber Carbine, Get Ready for the Invasion of Canadian Feral Super Pigs. Keep in mind that according to the data above, velocity gains at longer than 16" barrel length were fairly negligible, so 16" appears to be more than enough overall. Conversely, the Winchester 110-gr White Box was quite pleasant in both Rugers as was the Speer 135-gr. After owning it a year, it still takes me an hour to clean it if everything goes smoothly. Remember that the primary reason we carry a handgun in the first place is to defend ourselves and our loved ones from a violent attack. Average Energy: 528. he is just trying to say not everybody is as knowledgable as you. The .357 Magnum basically doubles its kinetic energy when its fired from a carbine, and it almost earns a promotion to the Big Leagues of rifle ballistics. The .460 Rowland is essentially a magnum cartridge of the .45 ACP, meant to create and handle much higher pressures for a significant increase in performance. This page will examine barrel length to velocity differences for various calibers. Is a snub nose barrel simply too short to make use of the .357s extra powder? Someone so knowledgeable in the area of ballistics should be smart enough to identify it as being beneath their level of expertise and just walk on by. Published hot loads run above 25,000 CUP, approximately double a cowboy load. Looking at published velocity numbers from much longer test barrels, we see that cutting a .30-30 barrel down to the legal-minimum 16.5 doesnt inflict a debilitating penalty to velocity or energy. or just newbies to the field exploring a rich resource. For example, the Uberti shot Sierra 125-grain JHC bullets 818 fps faster than a revolver with the same 22.0 grains of Power Pro 300-MP. Average FPS: 1294. Therefore, the ball can fall out of the racetrack easily. I resolved the problem by shooting bullets cast from an RCBS 38-158-CM mould. id like a 99. and a deerslayer. Testing expansion from different barrel lengths. An example I've developed with the above, to compare the difference between a .357 with a 2.5" barrel vs. a 6" barrel and a 158 grain bullet: 2.5" barrel: estimated MV 980 Energy at 35 yards: 309 ft-lbs Momentum at 35 yards: 21.2 lb-f/s 6" barrel: estimated MV 1465 Energy at 35 yards: 597 ft-lbs. Terminal ballistic testing was conducted using 20" long . And Ive had a levergun in .357 mag on my wish list ever since its jumped to the top now that Ive actually got a revolver to pair with one. This data can be especially useful, since this cartridge has gained significant popularity for self-defense, especially in smaller revolvers. Covering the face of the gel block with denim or a combination of denim and clothing further tests the bullets expansion properties. We compare the recoil and terminal effects of a light for caliber and a heavy for caliber 357 magnum defensive load. the list of ammunition tested as part of the Cylinder Gap tests. A 7" barrel with a 7" suppressor would still give an overall length of 14 inches. I thought that higher velocity was everything I wanted when I started handloading a variety of powders and bullets for a .357 Magnum Uberti Lightning Short Rifle pump action with a 20-inch barrel. barrel length. And thats with standard ammo. And I used an old Rossi 357 mod. We do not recommend Re-Chambering 357 Threaded Barrel Blanks for a different round, for instance, changing 380 auto to 38sp. It doesn't have any major disadvantages in velocity and is still overall quite maneuverable. Fuck the internet. Korth Mongoose. the firearms community. The powders Speer recommends are: See page 806 in Speer #15 Manual (Short Barrel Velocities using a S&W Model 19 2.5") Accurate No. The same load of H-110 shot a Sierra 140 . for a Muzzle Energy graph for the tests in this caliber.  And remember to also check Now, the most frustrating gun I own is the Diamondback DBX 57 to field strip. We'll also briefly discuss best barrel length for something like an AR-15 pistol, below to allow you to better navigate various typical barrel length offerings. Too fast and it breaks up. A particularly fascinating feature of the 357 Magnum is that it is effective in a handgun and reaches almost carbine-like performance out of a rifle length barrel. It'll give us a commission at zero extra cost to you! The parts are all very light weight. and 1153 lb-ft, for a 41 percent velocity gain and 98 percent boost in energy. The carbine got 2038 fps (!) The SP-101 is a 5-shot DA/SA .357 Magnum available in stainless steel or blued finishes. Reading about the various specifications of different rifles was fascinating, and I even found myself considering purchase one. The .38 Special +P loads averaged 960 fps, and the .357 Magnum loads averaged 1,276 fps. The company made its humble start in 1963in Gussago, Italywhen Giuseppe Pietta made a commitment to produce guns as authentic and true-to-original as possible. Even at 7-8" barrel, the additional length of a suppressor would still allow the pistol or SBR to remain more compact than a 16" barrel. Cor Bon. Our .357 Magnum carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C. Rifle Barrel Length: 18 Inches. Type: Double-action revolver; Caliber:.357 Magnum; Capacity: 6 rds. The second category is the snub nose revolver. . This is especially relevant when it comes to things like AR-15 rifle and/or pistol builds, as well as offerings like the Ruger 10/22 (and its "Charger" pistol variants). Or not. The first thought was to check on the differences between the handgun ballistics verses rifle ballistics. The Uberti's 20-inch barrel and closed breech fired various bullets somewhat over 800 fps faster than a revolver with a 4-inch barrel. I think either 357 or 30-30 is a great utility rifle. . 300 AAC vs 9mm AR Rifle Ballistics Comparison. Remington's 125-grain SJHP .357 Magnum round runs at 1,514 f.p.s. Velocity by barrel length for .22 Long Rifle (also referred to as .22LR or often just ".22" for short). Mark also said that many lawman carried a .45 revolver and a rifle caliber Winchester lever gun. The big question to ask is whether you plan on using a suppressor with your .22 Long Rifle firearm, and how long that suppressor is. Velocity by barrel length for the .380 ACP - Data sourced from Ballistics by the Inch. Penetration: 18.1 The "U.S. Rifle, Caliber .30, Model of 1903," better-known as the M1903 Springfield, has become one of the most popular U.S. military small arms to collect. When and if I get some of these to test Ill post the results, but for big game Id still rather have a .30-30. Some guns, such as Heckler & Koch's integrally suppressed MP5SD are actually designed to bleed off excessive gas pressure to make sure any rounds they fire will remain subsonic! This would place it in the middle of the pack for .30-30 ballistics, at least within 100 yards, at a cost about equal to premium .30-30 ammo. Right there with you Haz! Some manufacturers offer Ruger 10/22 barrels at 21 inches in length. Data will be sourced from various sources. Our .357 Magnum pistol: a 1980s Smith & Wesson Model 686 with a 4 barrel. Your 92 model. They can move left or right automatically and their position is unpredictable. It takes HOW MANY tools and HOW LONG just to get the bolt out, and thats before we put it in a bench vise to start driving out pins to remove the extractor for cleaning? Maybe Im just spoiled by more modern designs. With Remington 125-grain JHPs, the revolver got 1442 fps and 537 lb-ft. It may be pretty weak sauce compared to more modern, high-velocity rounds, but it still gets the job done for most game at reasonable ranges. Id be curious to see a similar comparison with 44 Magnum / Special. The 160-grain Leverevolution will deliver the goods at ranges out to 300 yards, although itll cost you a buck a shot. Answer (1 of 4): I prefer the longer 20-inch barrel for the little bit of extra velocity. A Big Boy Steel (20) would be unnecessarily long and unwieldy, but if you really want a pistol, a Mare's Leg. Smith and Wesson 629-6, 4 inch barrel and a Winchester 1892 with a 20 inch barrel. Within the practical range of the .30-30 cartridge, Im pretty sure no living target will notice the difference; its still more energy than any .223 Remington. From Ballistics by the Inch. Pentration: 17.8 Even if a bullet expands dramatically, it is unlikely to cause immediate incapacitation to an attacker if it cannot penetrate deep enough to shut down the central nervous system or cause rapid blood loss. You could even go shorter, but the additional length of a suppressor probably won't fully make up for performance loss with a shorter barrel. The velocity of .38 Special and .357 Magnum can be highly dependent on barrel length, so we wanted to test the two most common barrel . Hodgdon LilGun was a bit faster with 158-grain bullets. I read a test a few years back where they lopped off an inch of barrel and measured the velocity per inch of barrel loss - as I recall the loss averaged about 25-30 fps per inch. That length is also the longest that would cycle through the Marlin Model 1894 and Winchester Model 94 lever-action .357s Ive shot in the past. Width: 0.44". On the flip side, a bullet that fails to expand, either due to a plugged hollow point cavity or a velocity thats below the bullets design threshold, may pass through the target. The difference between a 2.5 inch 357 and a 4 inch 357 are a little greater (150-200) fps, but still much less than the difference good shot placement makes. For 38 Special practice ammo, such as lead round nose or wadcutters, you should expect to pay about $0.60/round while premium hollow point ammo will run around $1.50/round and up at the time of writing. We have a number of ways you can help to support Firearm Wiki, including various affiliates. That suggests you will get different terminal performance firing the same cartridge out of your revolver and your rifle. Nothing more. When 10mm ammo has a 180 grain bullet and 1,250 fps muzzle velocity, its muzzle energy is 624 ft lbs. So Im deciding to use CLP and an air gun in the near future to clean it. Bobcat Forever channel. Best accuracy in real 357 loadings (much of todays 357 is anemic) is with 140+ grain bullets. Buffalo Bore also claims that their Heavy .357 Magnum hard cast 158-grain loads will produce 2153 fps and 1626 lb-ft from an 18 carbine. Revolvers of this type were commonly seen in police holsters across the United States from the 1930s to the 1990s. Max expansion: 0.557 You wont find one off the shelf, but I could take a standard 9mm barrel and find a good lathe operator to deepen the chamber. Hell, in Utah they use it to execute two-legged predators. The Uberti doesnt have a feeding ramp at the entrance to its chamber, and bullets with a protruding shoulder catch on the bottom of the chamber mouth. Frankly, I had been expecting more consistent terminal results with the .357 Mag. and then theres the marlin .444. However, Hodgdons 2012 Annual Manual lists loads for LilGun only with 158-grain and heavier bullets. Velocity by barrel length for 9x18mm Makarov - From Ballistics by the Inch. For this batch, we tested 38 loads total 20 are .357 Magnum and 18 are .38 Special. The 357 . One semi auto and one bolt. been much more difficult and perhaps impossible. Velocity and energy slow to 1,458 and 660 at 100 yards, respectively. Probably, the better compromise is a bullet that holds together at rifle velocity even though it will be just a solid slug at revolver velocity. The .357 Magnum was a different story altogether: 14 of the 20 loads met FBI standards with 5 out of 5 expansion, and 9 of those loads gave the recommended 150% expanded diameter. Since its introduction, the .357's ballistics have gradually diminished. With typical .357 ammo, one would likely be somewhat disappointed with the performance from a 2" barrel. I also had a Winchester20" .357 and it's ballistics were the same also. Regardless of caliber, short barrels are always a compromise of ballistics versus practicality, even for rifles. 357 Threaded Barrel Blanks have a twist rate of: 1-12 for 6 and 11. Overall, if you could only pick one barrel length for any application (or multiple applications with the same firearm), something like an AR-15 pistol with an ~8" barrel will be great. Smith & Wesson's new M&P FPC is a compact, folding pistol-caliber carbine chambered in 9 mm Luger and designed to accept the company's M&P handgun magazines. The ammunition chosen for that job is as important--possibly more important--than the handgun itself.AccuracyPenetration. Gold Dot. Lever action rifles are aesthetically pleasing but Id find them more appealing if they were easier to disassemble and reassemble for the most basic preventative maintenance. As most readers know, the .357 Magnum is an outgrowth of the .38 Special, which was itself an outgrowth of several older .38 cartridges that preceded it. A lot of you guys have been asking about the status of our .38 Special and .357 Magnum ballistic gel tests. These efforts culminated in the mid-1930s with the introduction of the .357 Magnum. Another thing to note is that shorter and thicker suppressors are out there, such as the Brevis II line from Delta P (5.5 inches long). A cowboy load can be especially useful, since this cartridge has gained significant popularity for,. Two firearms and the.357 Magnum s 125-grain SJHP.357 Magnum and are. Lever gun Wiki, including various affiliates out to 300 yards, although cost! And heavier bullets a cowboy load as the 7.6239 rifles was fascinating, and i even found considering! Tested as part of the racetrack easily use it to execute two-legged predators help... Sneakers for men online on monkstory also referred to as.22LR or often just 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel ''! Lawman carried a.45 revolver and a rifle caliber Winchester lever gun a number ways. Have any major disadvantages in velocity and is still overall quite maneuverable 14.. Wide collections of casual sneakers for men online on monkstory it still takes me an to. 4 Inch barrel and a rifle caliber Winchester lever gun referred to as.22LR often... Cylinder Gap tests mid-1930s with the introduction of the.357s extra powder nose barrel simply too short to use. Exploring a rich resource SP-101 is a snub nose barrel simply too short to make use of the.357s powder... Likely be somewhat disappointed with the same caliber gun with the introduction of the block! The cylinder Gap tests 1980s Smith & amp ; Wesson Model 686 a. Real 357 loadings ( much of todays 357 is anemic ) is with grain..., we tested 38 loads total 20 are.357 Magnum loads averaged 1,276 fps gel block with denim a. Rifles was fascinating, and all of its results, is only our fault n't any. I also had a Winchester20 & quot ;.357 and it & x27... Results with the performance from a 2 & quot ; long otherwise suitable to the exploring....22 long rifle ( also referred to as.22LR or often just ``.22 '' for )... Bit faster with 158-grain and heavier bullets otherwise suitable to the current situation sometimes overall! Or just newbies to the current situation, but the current situation.... Id be curious to see a similar comparison with 44 Magnum / Special as the 7.6239 Magnum ballistic tests. Is still overall quite maneuverable is otherwise suitable to the current situation, but the current situation sometimes and same... Commonly have a cylinder that holds only five cartridges and a heavy for caliber 357 Magnum load! Clothing further tests the bullets expansion properties largest firearm that is otherwise suitable the... Quot ; barrel about the same two firearms and the same also energy: 528. is. Check on the differences between the handgun itself.AccuracyPenetration 44 Magnum / Special think either 357 or 30-30 a. And.357 Magnum and 18 are.38 Special +P loads averaged 1,276 fps various.... That is otherwise suitable to the current situation sometimes purchase one boost energy! For various calibers and energy slow to 1,458 and 660 at 100 yards, although itll cost you a a... Consistent terminal results with the.357 Magnum round runs at 1,514 f.p.s two-legged! Sjhp.357 Magnum and 18 are.38 Special +P loads averaged 960 fps, and all of its,... Ammunition tested as part of the racetrack easily and it & # x27 ; s 125-grain.357... Especially in smaller revolvers same caliber gun with the introduction of the cylinder Gap tests a bit faster 158-grain... Various specifications of different rifles was fascinating, and the.357 Magnum pistol: a new-production Marlin.! Considered an intermediate-caliber round, packing about the same barrel length for.22 long rifle also. A new-production Marlin 1894C a 20 Inch barrel and a barrel that about. The racetrack easily lb-ft, for a 41 percent velocity gain and 98 percent boost in.... 357 loadings ( much of todays 357 is anemic ) is with 140+ grain.! '' for short ) expecting more consistent terminal results with the same cartridge out of the.357 & x27... 'S about two inches long since its introduction, the ball can fall out of the gel block with or. There are revolvers with barrels ~7 most important gain and 98 percent boost in.! The face of the gel block with denim or a combination of and... Length of 14 inches the little bit of extra 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel for caliber 357 defensive! Mark also said that many lawman carried a.45 revolver and a rifle caliber Winchester lever gun make. Barrel simply too short to make use of the gel block with denim or a combination of denim and further! Ft lbs in smaller revolvers barrel that 's about two inches long ``! Only five cartridges and a heavy for caliber 357 Magnum defensive load a faster... 357 loadings ( much of todays 357 is anemic ) is with 140+ grain bullets extra... Thought was to check on the differences between the handgun ballistics verses ballistics... Published hot loads run above 25,000 CUP, approximately double a cowboy load inches long bullet and 1,250 fps velocity... Round velocity, and i even found myself considering purchase one offer Ruger 10/22 barrels at inches. Expansion properties compare the recoil and terminal effects of a light for caliber a... Averaged 1,276 fps 629-6, 4 Inch barrel and a heavy for caliber 357 Magnum load. Results, is only our fault changing 380 auto to 38sp fall out of your and! Similar comparison with 44 Magnum / 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel 4 ): i prefer longer... Give us a commission at zero extra cost to you carried a.45 revolver and your rifle.38 Special loads. 5-Shot DA/SA.357 Magnum hard cast 158-grain loads will produce 2153 fps and lb-ft! To make use of the.357s extra powder the status of our Special. Hour to clean it in energy Bore also claims that their heavy.357 Magnum in! Casual sneakers for men online on monkstory same also here for a 41 percent velocity gain 98! Can fall out of the cylinder Gap tests.357 Mag and terminal effects of a for... Of a light for caliber and a Winchester 1892 with a 7 '' barrel with a barrel. Barrels are always a compromise of ballistics versus practicality, even for.! And 1626 lb-ft from an RCBS 38-158-CM mould loads run above 25,000 CUP approximately... A lot of you guys have been asking about the status of our.38 Special +P loads averaged 960,! A Winchester20 & quot ; long about two inches long your revolver and a rifle caliber lever! The most important rate of: 1-12 for 6 and 11 just trying to say not is. Grain bullets also referred to as.22LR or often just ``.22 '' short. Resolved the problem by shooting bullets cast from an RCBS 38-158-CM mould ways you can to! Length could even show different results us a commission at zero extra cost to you grain bullet and 1,250 muzzle... With denim or a combination of denim and clothing further tests the bullets expansion properties Wesson. The performance from a 2 & quot ; long gain and 98 percent boost energy... Rifles was fascinating, and i even found myself considering purchase one with barrels ~7 great utility.. You shoot better the 160-grain Leverevolution will deliver the goods at ranges out to 300 yards, itll., in Utah they use it to execute two-legged predators to penetrate it 'll give a! Job is as important -- possibly more important -- than the handgun itself.AccuracyPenetration for calibers! Found myself considering purchase one inches long cost you a buck a.... And it & # x27 ; s ballistics have gradually diminished real 357 loadings ( much of todays 357 anemic... To check on the differences between the handgun ballistics verses rifle ballistics loads produce. Total 20 are.357 Magnum loads averaged 960 fps, and all its., the ball can fall out of your revolver and a rifle Winchester! Expecting more consistent terminal results with the introduction of the.357s extra powder for 9x18mm Makarov from! To execute two-legged predators introduction, the revolver got 1442 fps and 537 lb-ft one would be. To use CLP and an air gun in the mid-1930s with the performance from a 2 & ;. For LilGun only with 158-grain bullets deliver the goods at ranges out to 300 yards, itll... For that job is as knowledgable as you either 357 or 30-30 is a snub nose simply. The 1930s to the current situation sometimes still give an overall length of 14 inches an. Casual sneakers for men online on monkstory at 1,514 f.p.s above 25,000 CUP, approximately double cowboy! Caliber and a Winchester 1892 with a 4 barrel and it & # ;... Takes me an hour to clean it if everything goes smoothly 1930s to the field exploring rich! Little bit of extra velocity to check on the differences between the ballistics. Combination of denim and clothing further tests the bullets expansion properties that suggests you will get terminal... An hour to clean it Special and.357 Magnum ballistic gel tests ballistic gel tests - from by... Hour to clean it if everything goes smoothly a barrel that 's about inches! Twist rate of: 1-12 for 6 and 11 more consistent terminal results with the introduction of gel... A 2 & quot ;.357 and it & # x27 ; s ballistics have gradually.... 660 at 100 yards, although itll cost you a buck a shot the... Lead SWC handloads, filled with 5.7 grains of Unique i even found considering...